Mission Grey Daily Brief - October 26, 2024
Summary of the Global Situation for Businesses and Investors
The war in Ukraine continues to dominate global affairs, with North Korean troops moving towards the frontline and Russian forces suffering record casualty rates. Elon Musk is accused of having close ties with Vladimir Putin, withholding Starlink access from Taiwan as a favour to China. US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen announced new sanctions targeting secondary entities in countries supplying Russia with critical items for its military. Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko threatened war if Russia attempts to annex Belarus. South Korea is threatening to arm Ukraine in response to North Korea's support for Russia. Putin hosted the BRICS summit in Russia, praising its role as a counterbalance to the West's "perverse methods", and pushing for the creation of a new payment system as an alternative to the SWIFT network. Israel launched a retaliatory strike on Iran.
Russia's War in Ukraine
The war in Ukraine continues to be a major concern for businesses and investors, with the conflict entering its 975th day and Russian forces suffering record casualty rates. North Korean troops are moving towards the frontline, posing a significant threat to Ukraine's defence. Vladimir Putin is pulling Kim Jong Un deeper into the war, revealing a weakness in the Kremlin's ability to recruit troops at home. North Korea's infusion of fresh soldiers will remain practically risk-free for Pyongyang, unless the United States returns to its aggressive sanctions posture against the Kim regime. Russia is no stranger to employing foreign armies, with Cossack warriors famously fighting for the tsars in centuries past and the Red Army bolstering its ranks with Mongolian troops when it invaded China at the end of World War II. Today, the "TikTok soldiers" of Chechen warlord Ramzan Kadyrov are scattered across Ukraine's front lines.
After nearly three years of fighting, Putin is running low on cannon fodder. The Kremlin is finding it difficult and expensive to entice more of Russia's poor and desperate to sign up for the war, even with promises of bonuses and good pay. In theory, Moscow could force millions of its fighting-age men into the Ukrainian meat grinder through conscription, but this option is politically perilous. The Putin regime discovered the dangers of the draft when it briefly attempted a "partial mobilization" in September 2022, with Russians responding with howls of opposition. The government quickly backed off of the effort, informing many that their call-up orders were issued by "mistake". Since then, Russia has relied on mercenary groups and lucrative payouts to make the "golden handshake" in exchange for military service in Ukraine. Even these enticements are proving to be insufficient for the Kremlin's manpower needs.
By providing fresh troops to Russia, North Korea will likely help to backfill some, but not all, of Moscow's gaps. US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin warned the news is a "very, very serious issue", but cautioned that the precise contribution of Pyongyang's troops remained unknown. For the Kim regime, support for Russia has many strategic benefits and few risks. First, protection from United Nations sanctions. Russia has used its Security Council veto to repeatedly shield North Korea from international monitoring and penalties for its prohibited missile tests and nuclear weapons development. Second, a security guarantee from the world's largest nuclear power. This summer, Moscow and Pyongyang agreed to a NATO-style mutual defense pledge, promising to aid each other in the event of war. Third, North Korea's troops will gain valuable combat experience if they survive. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the Kim regime will likely benefit from Russian technology transfers that could greatly accelerate its missile and nuclear programs.
In exchange, the costs to North Korea are a pittance. An expeditionary force of roughly 12,000 soldiers is small potatoes compared to Kim's million-man army. His related shipments of around three million artillery shells to Russia is also a small fraction of his total stockpile. The danger to Ukraine is great, however, with a senior Ukrainian official stating that the addition of North Korean artillery on the battlefield has been "much worse than the Shaheds", the Iranian-designed kamikaze drones that Russia is using to pound Kyiv's troops and infrastructure.
Elon Musk's Alleged Ties with Vladimir Putin
Elon Musk is accused of having close ties with Vladimir Putin, withholding Starlink access from Taiwan as a favour to China. The Wall Street Journal reported that Putin asked Musk to withhold Starlink from Taiwan as a favour to China's Xi Jinping, with unnamed officials stating that Musk has been in regular contact with Putin since 2022. The Journal reported that in late 2023, Musk received his first request from the Kremlin to refrain from activating Starlink over Taiwan, citing a former Russian intelligence officer. The request was made for Beijing's sake, as Moscow increasingly relied on trade from China. Based on The Journal's findings, it's unclear exactly how many times Putin or his administration asked Musk for the favour.
The Chinese embassy in Washington told The Journal that it was not aware of the specifics of this arrangement, and did not respond to a separate request for comment sent outside regular business hours by Business Insider. Taiwan does not have official Starlink access because its laws require satellite services to be provided through a joint venture with a local operator that maintains majority ownership. The New York Times reported that SpaceX was unwilling to accept such an arrangement, and the self-governed island is thus creating its own low-earth orbit satellite network. Musk's reported conversations with Putin coincide with his apparent shift in rhetoric toward Ukraine in late 2022. Until that point, the billionaire had vocally supported Kyiv, providing it with 15,000 Starlink terminals.
In October of that year, he began seeking funding from the Pentagon to continue the free services, tweeting that they were taking a financial toll. Musk also tweeted a poll that month about a peace plan reflecting some of Russia's war demands at the time, including Russia's formal obtaining of Crimea and a guarantee of Ukraine's neutrality. The billionaire's post drew the fury of pro-Ukrainian accounts, but he added that he only suggested those measures to avoid further death in Ukraine and the risk of nuclear war. "Obviously, we are pro-Ukraine", he tweeted, saying that SpaceX had spent about $80 million on free Starlink for Ukraine. Two weeks later, Ian Bremmer, a political scientist who founded Eurasia Group, wrote in an email to his subscribers that Musk had spoken with Putin before tweeting this controversial peace plan. Per Bremmer, Putin had told Musk that if he could not accomplish his goals in Ukraine, he would turn to "major escalation". Musk and the Kremlin said Bremmer's report was untrue.
The allegations present awkward implications for the US, with Musk's SpaceX holding defense and space contracts with the Pentagon and NASA. An analysis published on Monday by The New York Times reported that the company has $3.6 billion in contracts with the Defense Department — primarily for launching American satellites into orbit — and $11.8 billion with NASA. Russian forces were reported to be buying up Starlink terminals earlier this year to help their invasion of Ukraine. The system has been vital to Ukrainian forces over the two-year conflict. But Russian agents are reportedly now using 'intermediaries' in Dubai in order to get their hands on the terminals, circumventing western sanctions imposed on Russia. House Democrats warned that Russia's use of the system in Ukraine could raise national security concerns in March. In a letter to SpaceX, two Democrats on the House Oversight Committee demanded information about Russia's potential illegal acquisition of the satellite-enabled terminals, according to the Washington Post. The letter cited recent allegations from Ukrainian intelligence officials, who say that Russian troops are using Starlink terminals to coordinate war efforts in eastern Ukraine, in potential violation of US sanctions.
As founder of SpaceX, Musk has cultivated close ties with US military and intelligence, with access to sensitive information. The company is the primary rocket launcher for both NASA and the Pentagon. Starlink has said it does not do any business in or with Russia, and Musk has branded claims of association with Putin "absurd". Dmitry Peskov, spokesperson for the Kremlin, insisted neither Putin nor the Kremlin were in regular contact with Musk. Musk has not yet commented on the claims published in the WSJ. The Kremlin today slammed the claims in the WSJ report as "not true" and "absolutely false". While Beijing remains officially neutral on the conflict between Russia and Ukraine, it has supported Putin's claims that the war was provoked by western aggression. The US this month imposed its first sanctions on Chinese firms for making weapons for Russia, accusing them of collaborating with Russian defence firms to produce drones vital to the war effort.
US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen Announces New Sanctions
US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen announced new sanctions targeting secondary entities in countries supplying Russia with critical items for its military. Yellen told world financial leaders gathered in Washington for annual meetings of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank that "We will unveil strong new sanctions targeting those facilitating the Kremlin's war machine, including intermediaries in third countries that are supplying Russia with critical inputs for its military". The IMF and World Bank meetings mark the last major international finance gathering to be held during President Joe Biden's administration and come as the state of the economy and inflation are top concerns for American voters. The presidential election between the Republican party nominee, former President Donald Trump, and Democratic party nominee Vice President Kamala Harris is slated to be decided on November 5, with the outcome expected to have an enormous impact on global finance and the world's economy.
Yellen touched on the use of the proceeds from frozen Russian sovereign assets to provide loans for Ukraine. As she spoke, the European Parliament approved a loan of up to 35 billion euros ($38 billion) for Ukraine's defense and reconstruction that will be repaid using future revenues from Russian central bank assets frozen abroad. Yellen referred to the overall $50 billion loan package being negotiated by the Group of Seven and EU allies, saying the United States expects to be able to contribute $20 billion. The U.S. Treasury Department is "working tirelessly to unlock the economic value of frozen Russian sovereign assets to aid Ukraine", Yellen said. Earlier on October 22, Britain announced its readiness to provide Ukraine with a loan of<co: 2>Earlier on October 22, Britain announced its readiness to provide Ukraine with a loan of
Further Reading:
As North Korea, Iran and China support Russia’s war, is a ‘new axis’ emerging? - CNN
If South Korea decides to get involved in Ukraine, it has powerful options - Business Insider
Israel launches retaliatory strike on Iran - Financial Times
Lukashenko warns of war if Russia attempts to annex Belarus - RBC-Ukraine
North Korea’s troops reveal Putin’s Ukraine pickle — no more cannon fodder - New York Post
Putin 'asked Elon Musk to switch off internet over Taiwan as a favour to China' - Daily Mail
Vance says it is Ukraine's decision to end the war - NBC News
Vladimir Putin signals North Korean troops are in Russia - Financial Times
Themes around the World:
Political Stability and Policy Predictability
France's domestic political climate, including election outcomes and policy continuity, affects investor confidence and long-term strategic planning. Political stability is crucial for maintaining favorable business environments and attracting foreign direct investment.
Trade Policy and Customs Procedures
Changes in Turkey's trade policies, tariffs, and customs procedures influence import-export efficiency. Streamlined processes can enhance trade flows, while protectionist measures may hinder market access and increase costs.
Infrastructure Development
Investments in transportation, ports, and digital infrastructure are critical for enhancing Mexico's trade competitiveness. Ongoing projects aim to improve logistics efficiency and connectivity, but delays and funding challenges may hinder supply chain reliability and increase operational risks for international businesses.
Technological Innovation and Digitalization
France's push towards digital transformation and innovation ecosystems fosters opportunities in tech sectors but also demands adaptation from traditional industries. Investment in AI, cybersecurity, and digital infrastructure influences competitive advantage and market entry strategies.
Commodity Export Restrictions
Indonesia's government has imposed export restrictions on key commodities like nickel and palm oil to boost domestic processing industries. This policy affects global supply chains, increasing costs and uncertainties for international buyers, while encouraging foreign investment in local processing facilities to capitalize on value-added production.
Trade Policy and Tariff Adjustments
India's evolving trade policies, including tariff revisions and emphasis on self-reliance (Atmanirbhar Bharat), affect import-export dynamics. Protective measures in certain sectors may challenge foreign companies, while new trade agreements and export incentives open avenues for market entry and expansion.
Infrastructure Development Initiatives
Significant investments in Indonesia's infrastructure, including ports, roads, and industrial zones, enhance logistics efficiency and reduce operational costs. These developments attract foreign direct investment by improving supply chain reliability and market accessibility, thereby strengthening Indonesia's position as a regional manufacturing and trade hub.
Regulatory and Legal Uncertainty
Frequent changes in Turkey's regulatory framework and legal ambiguities pose risks for international businesses. Unpredictable policy shifts can affect contract enforcement, taxation, and compliance costs, deterring foreign direct investment.
US-Vietnam Trade Relations Expansion
Strengthening trade ties between the US and Vietnam, including recent agreements and increased bilateral investments, enhance Vietnam's attractiveness as a manufacturing hub. This trend supports diversification of supply chains away from China, benefiting sectors like electronics and textiles, and encouraging foreign direct investment.
Labour Market Constraints and Immigration Policies
Stricter immigration controls post-Brexit have led to labour shortages in key sectors such as logistics and manufacturing. This constrains operational capacity and increases wage pressures, influencing investment in automation and workforce development initiatives.
Inflation and Economic Uncertainty
Rising inflation rates and economic uncertainty in Germany affect consumer demand and cost structures. Businesses face pressure on profit margins and investment returns, leading to cautious capital expenditure and strategic reassessments in market positioning and supply chain management.
Political Instability and Governance Challenges
Pakistan faces ongoing political instability marked by frequent government changes and governance issues. This volatility undermines investor confidence, disrupts policy continuity, and complicates long-term business planning, increasing risks for foreign direct investment and international trade partnerships.
Labor Market and Workforce Nationalization
The Saudization policy aims to increase employment of Saudi nationals, affecting labor availability and costs. This shift influences operational strategies for multinational companies and may impact productivity and compliance requirements.
Trade Agreements and Economic Partnerships
Saudi Arabia's active pursuit of bilateral and multilateral trade agreements expands market access and integrates the kingdom into global value chains. These agreements influence tariff structures and investment protections, shaping international trade strategies.
Environmental Regulations and Sustainability
Stricter environmental policies and enforcement, especially concerning the Amazon rainforest, are shaping Brazil's business landscape. Compliance with sustainability standards is increasingly demanded by global partners, affecting sectors like agriculture, mining, and energy. Environmental risks also influence reputational and operational aspects of international trade.
Economic Diversification Efforts
Vision 2030 drives Saudi Arabia's push to diversify its economy beyond oil, focusing on sectors like tourism, entertainment, and technology. These initiatives attract foreign investment, reshape supply chains, and create new business opportunities, reducing dependency on hydrocarbons and enhancing economic resilience.
Economic Growth and Inflation Trends
Brazil's economic performance, marked by fluctuating GDP growth and inflation rates, directly affects consumer demand and cost structures. Inflationary pressures influence monetary policy decisions, impacting interest rates and investment returns, crucial for strategic financial planning.
Labor Market Dynamics and Wage Growth
Rising wages and labor shortages in key industrial regions impact production costs and timelines. While improving living standards, these trends may prompt companies to invest in automation or relocate lower-skilled operations, influencing investment strategies and supply chain configurations.
Energy Supply Instability
South Africa faces ongoing energy supply challenges due to frequent power outages and load shedding by Eskom. This instability disrupts manufacturing and mining operations, increasing operational costs and deterring foreign investment. Businesses must factor in energy risks when planning supply chains and capital expenditures in the region.
China's Green Energy Transition
China's commitment to carbon neutrality by 2060 drives massive investments in renewable energy and electric vehicles. This transition creates new opportunities and challenges for international investors and supply chains, reshaping demand for raw materials and clean technology partnerships.
Currency Volatility
The South African rand experiences significant volatility due to domestic political developments and global market shifts. Currency fluctuations affect import costs, export competitiveness, and repatriation of profits, requiring businesses to implement robust hedging strategies to mitigate financial risks.
China's Economic Recovery Post-Pandemic
China's gradual economic reopening and stimulus measures are driving a rebound in domestic consumption and industrial output. However, uneven recovery and localized COVID-19 outbreaks pose challenges to stable growth, influencing foreign investors' confidence and operational planning.
Geopolitical Tensions and Border Security
Ongoing geopolitical tensions, particularly with neighboring countries, pose risks to regional stability and can disrupt trade routes and supply chains. Heightened border security measures and defense spending impact investor confidence and necessitate risk mitigation strategies for businesses engaged in cross-border operations.
Cross-Strait Political Tensions
Ongoing political tensions between Taiwan and China pose significant risks to international trade and investment. Escalating military activities and diplomatic pressures could disrupt supply chains, increase operational costs, and deter foreign direct investment, necessitating strategic risk mitigation for businesses engaged in the region.
Geopolitical Tensions in Southeast Asia
Indonesia's strategic location in the South China Sea exposes it to regional geopolitical tensions, impacting maritime trade routes. Businesses face risks related to potential disruptions in shipping lanes and increased security costs.
Trade Agreements and Regional Integration
Brazil's engagement in regional trade agreements, such as Mercosur, and negotiations with global partners shape its trade environment. Changes in tariff structures and trade policies impact market access and supply chain configurations, influencing international business strategies.
Regulatory Environment and Business Climate
Taiwan's regulatory policies, including intellectual property protection and foreign investment regulations, shape the business environment. Recent reforms aim to enhance transparency and investor confidence, affecting strategic business decisions.
Trade Policy and Tariff Adjustments
Recent changes in trade policies, including tariffs and export controls, affect the cost and flow of goods. These measures influence multinational companies' sourcing decisions and market access, reshaping global trade patterns involving the US.
Economic Volatility and Inflation
Turkey faces persistent high inflation and currency volatility, undermining purchasing power and increasing operational costs. This economic instability complicates long-term investment planning and raises risks for foreign investors concerned about returns and capital preservation.
Humanitarian Crisis and Workforce Impact
The ongoing conflict has triggered a humanitarian crisis, leading to population displacement and labor shortages. This demographic shift affects workforce availability and consumer markets, influencing operational capacity and demand forecasts.
Sanctions Impact on Trade
International sanctions on Iran, particularly from the US and EU, severely restrict Iran's ability to engage in global trade, limiting export opportunities and access to foreign capital. These sanctions affect sectors like oil, banking, and shipping, increasing transaction costs and complicating supply chains for businesses operating in or with Iran.
Infrastructure and Logistics Challenges
Aging infrastructure and limited access to modern logistics networks hinder efficient trade operations. Constraints in transportation, port facilities, and customs processes increase costs and delivery times, affecting supply chain efficiency for international companies.
Energy Supply Constraints
Chronic energy shortages and unreliable power supply hinder industrial productivity and increase operational costs. Energy constraints limit manufacturing output and affect Pakistan's competitiveness in global supply chains.
Supply Chain Diversification Efforts
Vietnam is actively attracting manufacturers relocating from China due to rising costs and geopolitical risks. This shift bolsters Vietnam’s role as a critical node in global supply chains, particularly in electronics and textiles, but also requires infrastructure upgrades to sustain growth.
Digital Economy and Technology Adoption
Rapid digitalization and technology adoption in India, including growth in e-commerce, fintech, and digital payments, transform business models and consumer engagement. This digital momentum enhances operational efficiencies and opens new avenues for investment, particularly in technology-driven sectors, reshaping the competitive landscape for global players.
USMCA Trade Agreement Dynamics
Canada's trade relations under the USMCA framework remain pivotal, influencing tariffs, regulatory standards, and cross-border supply chains. Recent negotiations and enforcement issues affect sectors like automotive and agriculture, impacting investment decisions and operational planning for businesses engaged in North American markets.